Two rooftop pool bids can show the same pool dimensions and come in at very different prices. Before you compare totals, check where each contractor’s scope starts and ends. A shell delivered to the jobsite is a different scope from a pool that’s installed, filled, tested, and ready for the building to operate.
If you’re pricing a rooftop pool for a New York City condo, hotel, or private club, give every bidder the same drawings and have them mark each line item included, by others, or allowance. If it’s by others, name the trade responsible. If it’s an allowance, ask what the number assumes and how it will be reconciled.

1. Roof structure and design coordination
Identify who verifies the roof can support the filled vessel, finishes, equipment, and people, and who pays for any reinforcement. Ask who provides the operating weights, support locations, and installation loads to the structural engineer. Confirm who prepares the pool drawings, coordinates them with the architect and engineer, and handles any required filings or inspections. Don’t assume those services are included just because the estimate says “design-build.”
2. Pool shell, freight, crane, and rigging
Have the bidder name the vessel type, interior finish, delivery point, and exact scope of setting and securing it on the roof. Find out who supplies the crane, riggers, staging, street permits or traffic control if needed, and who carries the cost if the lift is rescheduled. For permit details, see the NYC Department of Buildings crane permit guidance. When comparing stainless steel and an EPS-based system, compare installed bids with equivalent finishes and equipment. Delivery, assembly, waterproofing, and finishing responsibilities can differ enough to change which option actually costs less.
3. Roof waterproofing, deck drainage, and finishes
The watertight pool vessel and the building’s roof membrane are separate systems. Identify who owns the membrane, penetrations, deck drainage, and the details where the pool, coping, and roof meet. Confirm who protects the roof during installation and how the work affects the existing roofing warranty. List the actual finish materials and define where the pool contractor’s work stops and the surrounding deck work begins.
4. Pool equipment, plumbing, and electrical
Ask for an equipment list and a drawing that shows where each trade connects. Confirm who supplies and installs filtration, circulation, heating, sanitation, controls, and lighting, as applicable. Pin down who runs the piping and power to and from the equipment room, supplies drains, handles bonding, and provides freeze protection where needed. Check that pumps, filters, and other large components can be serviced or replaced without another rooftop lift.
5. Automatic pool cover
If you want an automatic cover, price it before the shell, coping, and deck are finalized. Confirm who provides the cover, tracks, recessed housing and lid, drainage, power, and controls. Have the bidder show how the motor can be accessed for service. If the cover is an alternate or an allowance, spell out which of those supporting items are already in the base bid.
6. Testing, commissioning, and turnover
Define what ‘ready to operate’ means in the contract. Clarify who pressure-tests piping, verifies watertightness, fills and balances the water, sets up the equipment and controls, demonstrates the cover, and trains the building team. Ask who coordinates applicable inspections, returns for any follow-up testing, and hands over warranties, manuals, and as-built drawings.
The last thing I’d check before signing
Put the pool contractor’s exclusions next to the GC’s scope. If both bids say ‘by others’ for the same drain, electrical feeder, cover vault, or crane permit, it isn’t covered. Assign it and price it before award. That one check can save a hard conversation when the shell is already on order.
Planning a rooftop pool in NYC? Send Aquatics International Group your plans for a feasibility review. Roof and equipment-room drawings, a proposed pool size, and any known access restrictions are a good starting point.